Hard Exam Questions from AQA A-Level Chemistry Paper 1

This guide is part of a series on difficult AQA AS/A-Level chemistry questions.

  • The guide to AS paper 1 and 2 is here
  • The guide to Paper 2 (organic and physical chemistry) is here
  • The guide to Paper 3 is here
Last Updated on December 12, 2023 by DrCarlThirsk

Key Points:

  • Unsurprisingly, multistep calculations are most often cited as difficult, particularly those relating to amount of substance, acids, bases and buffers, and thermodynamics.
  • Examiner’s often report that “only the best” A-Level chemistry students scored full marks on 6-mark level of response questions, reflecting their difficulty.
  • Kp calculations provide a greater challenge than Kc, especially when mole fractions and partial pressures are required.
  • Halogen redox chemistry, a problem at AS level, continues to cause difficulties at A-Level.
  • Transition metals is a problematic topic for many students, who find it difficult to contend with its formulae, equations, and advanced concepts.
  • Understanding, and writing equations for, the redox chemistry of cells and fuel cells is a challenging area.

Contents

Oh No, It’s The Inorganic and Physical Paper…

A lot of my students hate Paper 1 and its focus on inorganic and physical chemistry (as opposed to merely disliking papers 2 and 3).

It’s not hard to see why.

The physical chemistry topics (like acids, bases and buffers) are full of complex calculations that can even be a problem for strong mathematicians. Paper 1 also examines some of the hardest A-Level chemistry concepts to understand, and has tons of content to memorise that isn’t exactly very memorable. Who doesn’t love the random behaviour of the different transition metals, with all their different colours, complexes, and equations?

If you’re aiming for a top grade though, you have to meet the challenge of paper 1 head-on.

To help you do this, I have listed all the difficult paper 1 questions (according to examiner reports), and summarised the most frequently occurring areas of difficulty. These are your priority topics to understand and practise when studying:

Please do check out my guide to the difficult AS questions on papers 1 and 2 here.

Recurring Areas of Difficulty for Students

Here are the hardest topics, based on their appearance in examiner reports:

Amount of substance

  • Unstructured, multistep titration and back-titration calculations.
  • Writing and balancing chemical equations for unfamiliar reactions (particularly those described in words).
  • Unstructured, multistep ideal gas equation calculations.

Atomic structure

  • TOF-MS calculations, particularly involving rearranging equations.
  • Calculating isotopic abundances from RAM (especially involving algebra).
  • Describing the operation of the TOF mass spectrometer (particularly ionisation methods and determination of abundances).
  • Giving accurate definitions for key terms (e.g. RAM).

Acids and bases

  • Calculating the pH of buffers.
  • Calculating quantities needed to prepare a buffer of a given pH.
  • Using Kw to calculate pH of strong bases.
  • Relating pH and solubility.
  • Calculating the pH of a solution after partial neutralisation.
  • Understanding and applying extension concepts such as half-equivalence points.
  • Calculating the pH of solutions after dilution.
  • Understanding the logarithmic nature of the pH scale and how small quantities of acid/alkali produce large pH changes.

Bonding and structure

  • Drawing displayed formula for unfamiliar covalent molecules and ions.
  • The polarising ability of some ions.
  • Drawing diagrams to show hydrogen bonds for unfamiliar molecules.
  • The common AS misconception that covalent bonds are broken during melting and boiling is still present at A-Level.

Electrode potentials

  • Comparing oxidising/reducing agent ability based on standard electrode potentials
  • The chemistry of fuel cells, particularly half-equations for unfamiliar fuel cells.
  • Predicting or explaining reactions based on standard electrode potentials
  • The electrode reactions in a lithium-ion cell.
  • Deducing electrode half-equations from complete redox equations.

Equilibrium

  • Deducing or explaining optimal reaction conditions based on data and reaction characteristics.
  • Kp calculations and working out partial pressures from equilibrium data.

Inorganic chemistry

  • Writing redox reactions for reactions of halogens and halide ions.
  • Solubility of group 2 compounds.

Qualitative analysis

  • Precipitation reactions for metal ions, particularly those based on solubility.
  • Test-tube reactions to identify or distinguish metal ions.

Redox titrations

  • Multistep, unstructured redox titration calculations based on practical data .

Thermodynamics

  • Understanding how temperature affects Gibbs energy and feasibility.
  • Graphical representations of the Gibbs energy equation.
  • Using Born-Haber cycles to calculate quantities other than lattice enthalpy.
  • Experimental vs. theoretical lattice enthalpy (perfect ionic model).
  • Explaining trends in lattice enthalpy and hydration enthalpy.
  • Writing equations for standard enthalpy changes of specific substances.

Transition metals

  • Homogeneous catalysis.
  • Catalysis of the peroxodisulfate-iodide reaction.
  • Recalling equations for aqueous chemistry.
  • Stereoisomerism in complex ions.
  • Writing formulae for complex ions.
  • Explaining the origin of colour (and lack of colour) for transition metals.
  • ‘Flowchart’ questions, requiring you to work out colour and formulae of complexes, and reagents required.
  • Explaining/comparing the acidity of metal aqua ions.
Question NumberQuestion TypeTopicExaminer Comments
Q1.1Extended responseLattice enthalpyMany students struggled with the definition. Only the best students provided the correct definition.
Q1.3Extended responseLattice enthalpyMany students recognised the lattice wasn't purely ionic but struggled to link covalent character with stronger bonding.
Q2.2CalculationBuffersThis question differentiated well, with only 34.4% scoring full marks.
Q3.4CalculationKwAnother question that differentiated well, with many students not recognising that calcium hydroxide is dibasic.
Q3.5Extended responseGroup 2 compoundsThe idea that magnesium hydroxide is less soluble than calcium hydroxide was only appreciated by a few students.
Q4.4CalculationTOF mass spectrometryOnly the best students gained all marks. Many struggled with rearranging the equation.
Q6.6Extended responseGroup 2 compoundsMany students found the formula challenging and couldn't write a correct balanced equation.
Q6.7Extended responseBonding and structureMany students found this challenging; sulfuric(VI) acid was often incorrectly identified as the product.
Q8.2Extended responseTest-tube reactionsGood answers were rare. Most students failed to provide full observations.
Q9.16-mark Extended ResponseEquilibriaMost students failed to describe the information in the graph. Only the best noted the yield plateauing over about 850°C.
Q10.4Extended response / CalculationElectrode potentialsMany students struggled with this question. Incorrect answers included references to nitrate ions or sulfuric acid.
Q11CalculationDouble titration (redox and acid base) involving ethanedioic acid and sodium ethanedioateThis was a challenging question overall. Many students found most parts difficult, especially the displayed formula section.
Question NumberQuestion TypeTopicExaminer Comments
Q1.2CalculationLattice enthalpyMany students failed to divide the bond dissociation energy for oxygen by two. Over a third scored zero.
Q2.1CalculationKpMost students could calculate the partial pressure of ammonia but struggled with the other gases.
Q2.4Extended responseKp and Le Chatelier’s principleMost students mentioned the reaction was exothermic but didn't link it to Le Chatelier’s principle.
Q3.3Extended responseEntropyMany students couldn't state that the Gibbs energy would become more negative.
Q3.4Extended responseTransition metals (catalysis)Many students discussed general principles rather than the reaction on the platinum surface. Over 10% didn't attempt it.
Q3.6Extended responseAmount of substance (equations)Many students incorrectly identified hydrogen as the other product.
Q4.2Extended responsePeriodicityOnly the best students gained both marks. Many focused on electron removal from orbitals rather than nucleus-electron attraction.
Q4.3Extended responsePeriodicityLess than half of the students could give the correct answer; lithium was a common error.
Q4.6CalculationAtomic structureMany students tried to write algebraic expressions with two unknowns.
Q4.8CalculationTOF mass spectrometryMany students made errors in calculations, including not using the Avogadro constant correctly.
Q5.2CalculationAcids, bases and buffersOnly 20% of students scored full marks.
Q5.6CalculationAcids, bases and buffersJust over 40% of students scored full marks.
Q6.3Extended responseElectrode potentialsOnly just over 20% could state the required concentration for the left-hand electrode.
Q6.5Extended responseElectrode potentialsOnly the best students scored both marks. Many thought reagents would run out.
Q7.2Extended responseTransition metals (aqueous chemistry)Only a small proportion could give a correct equation. Over 10% didn't attempt this question.
Q7.3 & Q7.4Extended responseTransition metals (aqueous chemistry)Students were better at stating observations than writing equations.
Q8.16-mark Extended ResponseBonding and structureMany students used incorrect terminology in their answers or gave contradictory responses.
Q8.2CalculationIdeal gas equationMany students incorrectly identified sodium oxide as the product.
Q8.4Extended responseBonding and structureOnly 7% of students scored full marks.
Q9.1Multiple choiceTransition metals (vanadium chemistry)Only 11.3% scored both marks. The most common incorrect answer was Zn(II).
Q9.3Extended responseTransition metals (vanadium chemistry)Many students gave the structure as a mirror image and incorrectly identified the type of isomerism.
Q9.4 & Q9.5Extended responseTransition metals (vanadium chemistry)These parts were poorly answered, with many students providing incorrect equations.
Q10.1CalculationAmount of substance (back titration)This was a challenging question with 16.6% scoring all marks and 20% scoring zero.
Question NumberQuestion TypeTopicExaminer Comments
Q1.2CalculationLattice enthalpyMany students reversed the signs of some values or made errors with the electron affinity of iodine.
Q1.3Extended responseLattice enthalpyMany students did not recognise the minimal difference between experimental and theoretical values.
Q2.1Extended responseElectrospray ionisationMany students were unclear about how electrospray ionisation occurs and struggled with the equation.
Q2.3CalculationTOF mass spectrometryStudents had difficulty rearranging the equation and calculating the speed of the ion.
Q3.1Extended responsePeriodicityVery few students gave a correct explanation of periodicity.
Q3.5Extended responseAmount of substance (equations)Only about 25% of students could balance the given equation.
Q4.1 & Q4.4Extended responseTransition metals (colour & aqueous chemistry)Students struggled with the formula, colour of precipitates, and balancing equations.
Q5.2Extended responseInorganic chemistry (halogens)Students found this part challenging, especially in identifying the correct reagents and observations.
Q5.56-mark Extended ResponseTest-tube reactionsOnly the best students scored highly.
Q6.1CalculationRedox titrationStudents struggled with stoichiometric ratios and made errors in conversions.
Q6.5Extended responseTransition metalsMost students did not recognize that d-d transitions are not possible due to a full 3d sub-shell.
Q7.2CalculationKpStudents struggled with calculating partial pressures and understanding mole fractions.
Q8.1Extended responseBonding and structure (intermolecular forces)Answers were poor with many students omitting lone pairs or partial charges.
Q8.3Extended responseBonding and structure (shapes of molecules)Most students struggled with depicting the correct molecular shapes and bond angles.
Q9.2CalculationAcids, bases and buffersAnswers were poor with many students not understanding how to determine the pH at half-equivalence.
Q9.5CalculationAcids, bases and buffersVery few students could mathematically explain why the pH of solutions is volume independent.
Question NumberQuestion TypeTopicExaminer Comments
Q1.1CalculationLattice enthalpyMany students failed to divide their final answer by two.
Q1.4Extended responseLattice enthalpyMany students referred to atoms instead of ions. Few explained the attraction due to the ?? charge on the oxygen of water.
Q2.1Extended responseAtomic structureMany answers omitted reference to the average mass of an atom.
Q2.2CalculationAtomic structureMany students struggled with expressing in terms of one unknown.
Q3.1Extended responsePeriodicityStudents were divided over whether the second ionisation energy would be higher or lower than that of aluminium.
Q3.2Extended responsePeriodicityVarious incorrect answers were provided.
Q4.3CalculationAcids, bases and buffersStudents found this part challenging, especially in calculating the pH.
Q4.4CalculationAcids, bases and buffersMany found calculating the mass of salt needed for the buffer challenging.
Q5.1 & Q5.2Extended responseTransition metalsMany students struggled with the formulae of the complex ions and balancing equations.
Q5.4Extended responseTransition metalsA poorly answered question, with many students not understanding the acidity of metal aqua ions
Q6.1 & Q6.2CalculationEquilibrium & KpStudents had difficulty marking the cross accurately and calculating the partial pressure.
Q76-mark Extended ResponseIntermolecular forcesOnly the best students identified the correct intermolecular forces.
Q8.1CalculationRedox titrationMany students struggled with the calculation related to thiosulphate.
Q9.3Extended responseInorganic chemistry (halogens)Many students had difficulty identifying the correct oxidation or reduction processes.
Q10.1 & Q10.2CalculationEntropyMany students miscalculated the enthalpy change and entropy change.
Q11Extended responseElectrode potentialsThis question was challenging overall, especially Q11.4, which was the most difficult on the paper.
Question NumberQuestion TypeTopicExaminer Comments
Q1.1Extended responseLattice enthalpyMany students did not refer to constant pressure and often mentioned energy but not heat.
Q1.4Extended responseIonic bondingStudents found this challenging with errors in state symbols, equation directions, and enthalpy calculations.
Q2.1 & Q2.2Extended responseAtomic structureSome students confused mass with mass number and had errors in electron counts.
Q2.3CalculationAtomic structureOnly the most able students correctly calculated the isotopic abundances
Q3.1 & Q3.2Extended responsePeriodicity (period 3)Students often omitted state symbols or provided incorrect products.
Q4.16-mark Extended ResponseTransition metals (catalysis)Students found it challenging to define a heterogeneous catalyst.
Q4.2Extended responseTransition metals (catalysis)Catalysis of the peroxodisulfate-iodide reaction was not well understood.
Q4.4CalculationIdeal gas equationOnly some students were able to score full marks
Q4.7Extended responseTransition metals (aqueous chemistry)Students found it difficult to explain the relative acidities of iron(II) and iron(III) complexes
Q5.2CalculationKpStudents struggled with understanding equilibrium shifts and had issues with mole calculations.
Q6.1Extended responseAcids, bases and buffers (Kw)Students found it challenging to understand the effect of water concentration.
Q6.6Extended responseAcids, bases and buffers (pH)Very few students understood that small amounts of NaOH trigger large pH changes near the end point.
Q7.2Extended responseEntropyStudents often confused the disorder of gases with atomic structure and had issues with temperature conversions.
Q7.3CalculationEntropyThis 7-mark calculation on Gibbs energy and the temperature of feasibility discriminated well
Q8.1Extended responseElectrode potentials Few students provided a correct answer, with many not understanding electrode potentials.
Q8.5Extended responseElectrode potentials Most students were unable to give the correct explanation.
Q9.1Extended responseElectrode potentialsStudents found it very challenging to understand lithium's reaction with water in terms of electrode potentials
Q9.5Extended responseElectrode potentialsVery few students knew the cathode half-equation for the lithium ion cell
Question NumberQuestion TypeTopicExaminer Comments
Q1.1Extended responseEquilibrium21% of students gained both marks. Common errors included misconceptions about concentrations and reaction rates.
Q2.1Extended responseAtomic structureA third had errors in definitions.
Q2.5Extended responseAtomic structure (TOF-MS)Only 21% scored both marks in Q2.5.
Q3.1CalculationRedox titrationMost students struggled with Q3.1. Only 21% scored full marks.
Q3.2Extended responseRedox titrationOnly the most able were able to explain why an indicator is not required
Q3.5CalculationEnthalpy changesOnly 5% gained all marks by correctly calculating the bond enthalpy.
Q4.3Extended responseCatalysisQ4.3 was very challenging with few students achieving both marks.
Q4.4Extended responseAcids, bases and buffersOnly 5% were able to explain buffer action and score three marks.
Q4.5CalculationAcids, bases and buffersCalculating the buffer pH proved difficult, with only 40% scoring full marks.
Q5.3Extended responseTest-tube reactionsQ5.3 was challenging with only 13% scoring all marks.
Q5.5Extended responseAmount of substance (equations)Only 18% provided the correct equation.
Q5.76-mark Extended ResponseBonding and structureOnly 1 in 5 students scored marks at level 3, achieving 5/6 marks. Many students confused intermolecular forces and covalent bonds.
Q6.3Extended responseChemical reactionsOnly 33% scored both marks in Q6.3.
Q6.5Extended responseTest-tube reactionsQ6.5 was challenging with only 10% scoring all marks.
Q7.1Extended responseTransition metals (colour)43% scored both marks in Q7.1. by explaining the origin of a yellow complex.
Q7.5Extended responseTransition metals (aqueous chemistry)50% provided the correct equation.
Q8.1Extended responseElectrode potentialsLess than half gave a correct answer in Q8.1.
Q8.4Extended responseElectrode potentialsQ8.4 was very challenging with only 7% scoring both marks.

Strategies for Tackling Multistep Chemistry Calculations

Navigating through multistep calculations in A-Level Chemistry can be daunting, but it’s a skill you can master with the right approach. One of the most important things is to remember that complex calculations are not just about numbers, it’s also about understanding the logic behind each step.

Here’s how you can become more proficient in handling these challenges:

Understand the Logic

Start by understanding the ‘why’ behind each calculation. This means looking at each step not just as a number to crunch but as a part of a larger process. Knowing the reason for each step helps in retaining the method and applying it correctly. This is especially important with calculations that use experimental data. It’s really important to connect the data with the steps in the right way, otherwise you can start mixing and matching numbers with the wrong substances (for example, inadvertently combining a volume for one solution with the concentration of another).

Break Down the Problem

When faced with a complex problem, divide it into smaller sections. Tackle each section one at a time. This approach makes the problem more manageable and less overwhelming.

Diversify Your Practise

Regular practise is essential, but it’s important to vary the types of problems you work on. This ensures you are prepared for different scenarios and helps reinforce your understanding of the underlying concepts.

Develop a Methodical Approach

Create a systematic method for approaching common types of problems. This could be a checklist, or a set of steps that you follow. Having a consistent approach can be a reliable tool during exams.

For example, the steps required to solve acid-base titrations and redox titrations are largely the same, and the majority of calculations have many steps in common. Having a checklist that instructs you what to do at each step of the calculation can be very effective (though bear in mind, this won’t help with the hardest calculations that will require you to come up with an original solution).

Learn from Your Mistakes

Reviewing and understanding your mistakes is the most important part of studying.

Take time to analyse where you went wrong and why. This reflection is key to improving your problem-solving skills.

It’s about building a strong foundation in understanding the concepts and practicing systematically. With time and effort, you’ll gain confidence and proficiency in handling the complex paper 1 chemistry calculations that students often dread.

Memorising the Facts: Effective Techniques for A-Level Chemistry

If you’re struggling to keep track of all the factual content needed for paper 1, you’re not alone.

Inorganic chemistry is full of equations, reagents and reactivity trends. This knowledge must be committed to memory before it can be applied in questions.

Here are some effective ways to embed this information in your memory:

The Magic of Mind Maps

Mind maps are a game-changer for memorising connected concepts in chemistry. Start with a central concept and branch out to related topics, creating a visual web of information. This method helps in organising and connecting different pieces of information, making it easier to recall them during exams.

It works especially well for transition metals aqueous chemistry, to show the reaction pathways that connect different complex ions.

Flashcards: Your Portable Study Aids

Flashcards are a classic for a reason. They’re simple, versatile, and effective.

Write a key term or concept on one side and its explanation or definition on the other. Regularly reviewing these cards helps reinforce your memory and makes revision more interactive.

Some students like to make flashcards for common calculations. On one side, they write the question, on the other, they show the model answer, together with the relevant mathematical equation. This can also help you to get quicker at selecting the right approach for a given calculation, which is important when you’re up against the clock in the exam.

Regular Review Sessions

The key to memorisation is repeatedly and actively recalling information (aka active recall). Schedule regular sessions to go over your mind maps and flashcards. Use your mind maps and flashcards when answering past paper questions.

This consistent review helps transfer information from short-term to long-term memory, making recall easier during exams.

Teach What You Learn

One of the best ways to solidify your understanding of a concept is to explain it to someone else. Teaching forces you to organize your thoughts and explain concepts clearly, which in turn strengthens your own understanding and memory.

Connect New Information with What You Already Know

Linking new concepts to things you already understand can make them easier to remember. Try to find connections between new information and your existing knowledge. This creates a stronger mental association and aids in recall.

By incorporating these techniques into your study routine, memorising the huge amount of content needed for paper 1 becomes less daunting.

Remember though, effective memorisation is not about cramming; it’s about creating a structured and interactive way to engage with the material. With these methods, you’ll be well on your way to mastering the factual side of chemistry.

And please, do your poor teacher a favour and follow their advice: LEARN DEFINITIONS! A surprising number of discriminating questions on paper 1 simply tested straightforward recall of key definitions. You don’t want to be throwing away marks due to not memorising things.

Mastering Core Skills in Chemistry: Path to Fluency

Ever wondered how some students seem to have an effortless grasp of A-Level Chemistry?

I’m willing to bet that one of their secrets is they’ve spent time mastering the core skills. While others are struggling to remember mathematical formulae, or how to balance redox half-equations, they’re putting the finishes touches on their answer.

Here’s how you can build and refine these essential skills:

Consistent Practice

Consistency is key in mastering any skill.

Set aside regular time for practicing core chemistry skills. This could be solving equations, balancing reactions, or working through titration problems. The more you practice, the more natural these skills become. You’re aiming for fluency, so that the skills become almost automatic.

Focus on Understanding, Not Just Doing

When practicing, focus on understanding the ‘why’ behind each step. Don’t just go through the motions. Ask yourself why a particular reaction happens or why a certain rule applies. This deeper understanding will make your skills more adaptable.

Use a Variety of Resources

Don’t limit yourself to just textbooks.

Use a mix of resources like YouTube videos, websites, blogs, online tutorials, and interactive simulations. Different resources can offer new perspectives and explanations, helping to reinforce your understanding.

Apply Skills in New Contexts

Try applying your chemistry skills to new and different problems. This could mean tackling problems that are not directly from your textbook or syllabus. Applying skills in varied contexts helps to deepen your understanding and flexibility.

Get Feedback

Feedback is crucial for improvement. Work with teachers, tutors, or study groups to get feedback on your problem-solving approach. Understanding where you can improve helps you refine your skills more effectively.

Reflect on Your Learning

Take time to reflect on what you’ve learned and how you’ve applied your skills.

Reflective learning helps you understand your strengths and areas for improvement, guiding your future study sessions. By focusing on these strategies, you’ll develop a strong command of the core skills needed for paper 1.

Wrapping Up Our Tour of AQA A-Level Chemistry Paper 1

Mastering the hardest questions from AQA A-Level Chemistry paper 1 is about more than just memorising facts and formulae.

It involves developing a deep understanding of concepts, refining problem-solving skills, and effectively memorising facts.

By embracing the strategies we’ve discussed — breaking down complex calculations, using mind maps and flashcards for memorisation, and consistently practicing core skills — you’re setting yourself up for success.

How have these strategies worked in your study routine? Do you have any tips or experiences you’d like to share with fellow students? Drop a comment below and let’s continue the conversation!